By E.B. Tucker
Imagine logging into your brokerage account tomorrow and finding out that it’s frozen.Not just your account… every customer account at your brokerage is frozen.
You can’t buy stocks. You can’t sell stocks. You can’t move money out of the account.
Your account rep insists the money is still there. It’s just not available now. He doesn’t know when it will be.
When you demand to transfer $25,000 cash out of the account, he says, “I’m sorry… the system won’t let me.”
You ask to speak to his boss. She can’t help, either.
This situation sounds absurd to most Americans. There’s no way a major broker could freeze your accounts, right?
Wrong. It happened in 2011 to 38,000 people...
And this wasn’t some no-name broker. It was a highly respected, 228-year-old firm. And Jon Corzine ran it. At one point or another, Corzine was a US senator, the governor of New Jersey, and the CEO of Goldman Sachs. Then he became the CEO of MF Global.
MF Global handled stock and bond trading for some of Wall Street’s wealthiest clients.
It was also one of only 18 “primary dealers” at the time. Primary dealers are a select group of brokers allowed to participate in the US Treasury auction. Citigroup, Morgan Stanley, and Goldman Sachs are also primary dealers.
Like all US brokers, MF Global was required to keep customer cash and stock separate from its own corporate accounts. This rule is supposed to keep brokers from playing with customers’ money. But the rule only works if brokers follow it.
In October 2011, account holders at MF Global started having problems withdrawing cash and transferring stocks. Turns out that their money wasn’t there. MF Global had made a series of bad bets in European bonds and illegally transferred $891 million in customer funds to cover its trading losses.
Their cash was gone…
Customers had to hire and pay for their own attorneys. For a while, it looked like they’d never get their money back. But in December 2014, MF Global finally agreed to return $1.212 billion to its former clients. It also paid a $100 million fine.
You might be wondering how this sort of thing could happen...
First off, you are not the legal or registered owner of the stocks in your brokerage account. You’re just the “beneficial owner.”
Sure, you put the cash in your account. You logged in and “bought” Apple, GE, Verizon, and other stocks issued by sound companies. You did your homework because you worked hard for your money. Those investments are a key part of your retirement
And you work with a reputable broker. But your broker or a clearinghouse called Cede & Co.
Here’s how it works…
There are three basic ways to hold stocks: street name registration, direct registration, or physical certificate.
Cede & Co., a subsidiary of The Depository Trust Company (DTC), is likely the registered owner of your stocks. You are not the registered owner. When you buy a stock, DTC holds those shares for your broker. Your broker, in turn, holds those shares for you.
That means Apple, GE, Verizon, and the other companies whose stocks you hold have no record of you.
If your broker mishandles your account, you can sue to get your money back. But, as MF Global customers discovered, it’s not easy. And there’s no guarantee you’ll win...
If your broker makes a bad bet on Greece and uses your cash to settle the bill, you’re out of luck. Sure, it’s illegal… but laws didn’t stop MF Global. Customers had to take action, hire lawyers, and sue to get their cash back.
Stable markets hide problems. In 2008, we saw how big problems can go unnoticed for years. A crisis reveals who’s stable and who’s just pretending to be. Some brokers and financial institutions are heavily leveraged. They’re especially vulnerable in a crisis. Some will not survive the next one.
The MF Global fiasco is one of the most important financial stories of the past decade. It showed that the financial system isn’t as safe as you think it is. Even big, brand-name banks and brokerages with years of success can instantly go broke.
The next financial crisis will bring many more shams like MF Global’s to light. You can protect yourself by keeping plenty of cash and gold in a safe place… but not in a safety deposit box.
And make sure to diversify across financial institutions. You don’t want to get stuck in a situation like MF Global customers did… waiting years for your money because some executive gambled away the company.
P.S. Because this risk and others have made our financial system a house of cards, we’ve published a groundbreaking step-by-step manual on how to survive - and even prosper - during the next financial crisis. In this book, New York Times best-selling author Doug Casey and his team describe the three ESSENTIAL steps every American should take right now to protect themselves and their family.
These steps are easy and straightforward to implement. You can do all of these from home, with very little effort. Normally, this book retails for $99. But I believe this book is so important, especially right now, that I’ve arranged a way for US residents to get a free copy. Click here to secure your copy.
The article Why Your Brokerage Account Isn’t as Safe as You Think It Is was originally published at caseyresearch.com.
